Navigating the criminal justice system is stressful under any circumstance. However, for individuals who lack legal resident or citizen status, an arrest in Florida introduces an immediate, high-stakes intersection with federal immigration enforcement.
Whether facing a minor traffic infraction or a serious felony, an arrest sets off mandatory state-to-federal notification protocols. Understanding how Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) holds operate in Florida, why paying bond prematurely can backfire, and the legal hurdles involved is vital for defendants and their families.
The Reality of ICE Holds in Florida
Under Florida law, local law enforcement agencies must strictly cooperate with federal immigration enforcement. If an individual is booked into a county jail and does not possess legal resident or citizen status, the facility runs their information through federal databases. If a match appears, ICE issues an immigration detainer, commonly known as an ICE hold.
- No Exception for Minor Infractions: It does not matter if the underlying arrest stems from a minor traffic infraction or a major felony. Under Florida statutes, local jails are mandated to honor facially sufficient ICE detainers.
- Mandatory Compliance: Florida law prohibits local sanctuary policies. Jails must notify ICE of an inmate’s release date and hold them for up to an additional 48 hours so federal authorities can assume physical custody.
- Custody Transfers: Once transferred to ICE custody, securing a release becomes exceptionally difficult. Individuals are typically moved to federal immigration detention facilities, where bond eligibility is governed by federal rules and administrative backlogs.
The Danger of Paying Bond When an ICE Hold is Active
A critical mistake many families make is rushing to pay a criminal bond to get their loved one out of jail. Do not pay the state criminal bond if there is an active ICE hold.
- The Immediate Re-Arrest: If you pay the criminal bond, the local jail is technically required to release the individual from state charges. However, because the ICE detainer is active, the defendant will not walk out the front door. Instead, they are handed directly over to ICE agents. ICE has forty-eight hours to decide whether to pick up the defendant or not and from our experience, ICE has been picking everyone up.
- Financial Loss: Families lose the non-refundable bond premium paid to the bail bondsman (usually 10% of the total bond amount), yet the defendant achieves zero freedom.
- A Logistical Nightmare for Defense Attorneys: Once a client is transferred out of the local county jail and into federal immigration custody, coordinating legal access, scheduling meetings, and managing their state court defense alongside federal removal proceedings becomes a massive hurdle.
Navigating State Prosecution: Writs of Habeas Corpus Ad Prosequendum
When a non-citizen is transferred out of local custody and into federal ICE detention, pending state criminal charges still require a resolution. To bring the defendant back to face local court dates, the State of Florida must attempt to utilize a legal mechanism called a writ of habeas corpus ad prosequendum.
This writ acts as a formal court request asking federal immigration authorities to temporarily "loan" the defendant back to local custody to resolve pending criminal matters. However, dealing with this process involves major practical obstacles:
- Federal Discretion: Because the individual is in federal custody, the transfer relies entirely on federal cooperation. Good luck forcing the federal government to prioritize or smoothly follow the state order if logistical or jurisdictional conflicts arise.
- The "Catch-22" for Defendants: Many detainees oppose these writs out of fear that being pulled back into the state system will disrupt their ongoing immigration proceedings or bond strategies in federal custody.
Protect Your Rights with Experienced Legal Counsel
Facing criminal charges without legal status requires a defense team that understands both Florida criminal law and its heavy intersection with federal immigration policies. Moving forward without proper guidance risks immediate transfer to federal detention and severe long-term consequences. While we do not handle immigration cases, we will work closely with the immigration attorney to make sure that the criminal case is managed hand in hand with the immigration case.
Call Vento Law Firm Today
If you or a loved one is facing criminal allegations or an ICE hold in Florida, contact Vento Law Firm today for a confidential consultation.
Call me if you need me at 813-808-9088 or fill out our online contact form to schedule a confidential legal consultation.